How One Photograph Unraveled the Disappearance of an Entire Amish Family

someone—inside.

Behind the first buggy was a second vehicle. Not a buggy, but a truck, moving slowly with its headlights off.

“I only saw it for a moment,” Stevens says. “But I recognized the truck. It was Charles Benton’s. I’d seen it around the area before. He was following them.”

Stevens didn’t report what she’d seen. “I thought maybe they were just continue reading …